3 Times Roof Replacement Is Better Than Repairs

It is important to maintain the tip-top shape of your roof so you can have a safe and comfortable home year-round. However, there will come a time when roof repairs will not be enough to prevent persistent problems such as leaks and dry rot. In this article, Abby Windows & Exteriors, one of the most trusted roof and door replacement companies in the area, talks about the three times when a roof replacement is better than repairs.

roofing

  1. Your roof has reached its sell-by date. Each roofing material has its own sell-by date. While a clay or metal roof can last for more than 50 years, an asphalt shingle roof usually expires within two decades. If your current roof has sustained structural damage over the years and is nearing the end of its life, then you should consider replacing it.

  2. The water or storm damage to your roof is overwhelming. If a tall tree falls on your house during a storm event, the damage will likely be too widescale for a simple repair. As a general rule, roof repairs can only fix the damage that covers only 30 percent of the roof. If the scope of impairments exceeds that threshold, then purchasing a replacement roof from a local roof and new entry doors contractor is your smartest option.

  3. Any repair work will only be a temporary fix. Although a new roof is more expensive than a repair, sometimes it is a cost-effective choice to make. For example, if a new roof only costs between $500 to $1,000 more than the required repair service, it will probably be best to opt for the replacement roof. Most times, repair work may only give your roof another four to five years of use, while a completely new roof can give you another 20 years of use.

For roof replacement and new patio doors installation services, look no further than Abby Windows & Exteriors. Our certified team aims to deliver the comfort and efficiency that homeowners in Brookfield, WI, deserve. Call us today at (414) 209-3648 or fill out our contact form to request a free, no-obligation quote.

Our Reviews

Abby came to evaluate the job and make recommendations as to the type of windows and doors. We chose double-hung, triple-glazed Preservation windows and doors by Alside. Abby followed up by sending her lead measuring tech to get exact dimensions and make installation notes re: threshold modification, etc.

Kevin G.

Norb & I would like to thank you for the beautiful job you did on our home. It sure surpassed my wildest dreams! We have had contractors from hell, but you are contractors from heaven! You can sure count on us for great recommendations!

Donna & Norbert

Abby Home has done a great job with all of the work we have had done and we are confident that the window leaking problem has been solved. We would recommend your company to anyone needing to make some home improvements.

Rich & Michelle
Google
4.7
Rating
BBB
A+
Rating
Guild Quality
4.8
Rating
Angie's List
4.7
Rating

A Reputation Built on Results

BBB A+
affiliate-big50
logo-top-500
gaf-master-elite
expertise 2022 logo
bestpros
platinum-preferred
EPA lead safe
GAF certified

Contact Us

We Proudly Serve Homeowners and Businesses in Your Area
Abby Home Truck

Address
407 Pilot Ct, Suite 400B
Waukesha, WI 53188
Get Directions
Hours

Mon-Fri: 8am – 5pm
Sat-Sun: Closed

Phone Number
(414) 436-2229
© 2026 Abby Home. All Rights Reserved